openwrt_chaos_calmer/docs/adding.tex

Linux is now one of the most widespread operating system for embedded devices due
to its openess as well as the wide variety of platforms it can run on. Many
manufacturer actually use it in firmware you can find on many devices: DVB-T 
decoders, routers, print servers, DVD players ... Most of the time the stock 
firmware is not really open to the consumer, even if it uses open source software.

You might be interested in running a Linux based firmware for your router for
various reasons: extending the use of a network protocol (such as IPv6), having
new features, new piece of software inside, or for security reasons. A fully 
open-source firmware is de-facto needed for such applications, since you want to
be free to use this or that version of a particular reason, be able to correct a
particular bug. Few manufacturers do ship their routers with a Sample Development Kit,
that would allow you to create your own and custom firmware and most of the time,
when they do, you will most likely not be able to complete the firmware creation process.

This is one of the reasons why OpenWrt and other firmware exists: providing a 
version independent, and tools independent firmware, that can be run on various 
platforms, known to be running Linux originally.

\subsection{Which Operating System does this device run?}

There is a lot of methods to ensure your device is running Linux. Some of them do
need your router to be unscrewed and open, some can be done by probing the device
using its external network interfaces.

\subsubsection{Operating System fingerprinting and port scanning}

A large bunch of tools over the Internet exists in order to let you do OS 
fingerprinting, we will show here an example using \textbf{nmap}:

\begin{Verbatim}
nmap -P0 -O <IP address>
Starting Nmap 4.20 ( http://insecure.org ) at 2007-01-08 11:05 CET
Interesting ports on 192.168.2.1:
Not shown: 1693 closed ports
PORT   STATE SERVICE
22/tcp open  ssh
23/tcp open  telnet
53/tcp open  domain
80/tcp open  http
MAC Address: 00:13:xx:xx:xx:xx (Cisco-Linksys)
Device type: broadband router
Running: Linksys embedded
OS details: Linksys WRT54GS v4 running OpenWrt w/Linux kernel 2.4.30
Network Distance: 1 hop
\end{Verbatim}

nmap is able to report whether your device uses a Linux TCP/IP stack, and if so,
will show you which Linux kernel version is probably runs. This report is quite 
reliable and it can make the distinction between BSD and Linux TCP/IP stacks and others.

Using the same tool, you can also do port scanning and service version discovery.
For instance, the following command will report which IP-based services are running
on the device, and which version of the service is being used:

\begin{verbatim}
nmap -P0 -sV <IP address>
Starting Nmap 4.20 ( http://insecure.org ) at 2007-01-08 11:06 CET
Interesting ports on 192.168.2.1:
Not shown: 1693 closed ports
PORT   STATE SERVICE VERSION
22/tcp open  ssh     Dropbear sshd 0.48 (protocol 2.0)
23/tcp open  telnet  Busybox telnetd
53/tcp open  domain  ISC Bind dnsmasq-2.35
80/tcp open  http    OpenWrt BusyBox httpd
MAC Address: 00:13:xx:xx:xx:xx (Cisco-Linksys)
Service Info: Device: WAP
\end{verbatim}

The web server version, if identified, can be determining in knowing the Operating
System. For instance, the \textbf{BOA} web server is typical from devices running 
an open-source Unix or Unix-like.

\subsubsection{Wireless Communications Fingerprinting}

Although this method is not really known and widespread, using a wireless scanner 
to discover which OS your router or Access Point run can be used. We do not have
a clear example of how this could be achieved, but you will have to monitor raw 
802.11 frames and compare them to a very similar device running a Linux based firmware.

\subsubsection{Web server security exploits}

The Linksys WRT54G was originally hacked by using a "ping bug" discovered in the 
web interface. This tip has not been fixed for months by Linksys, allowing people
to enable the "boot\_wait" helper process via the web interface. Many web servers
used in firmwares are open source web server, thus allowing the code to be audited
to find an exploit. Once you know the web server version that runs on your device,
by using \textbf{nmap -sV} or so, you might be interested in using exploits to reach 
shell access on your device.

\subsubsection{Native Telnet/SSH access}

Some firmwares might have restricted or unrestricted Telnet/SSH access, if so,
try to log in with the web interface login/password and see if you can type in 
some commands. This is actually the case for some Broadcom BCM963xx based firmwares
such as the one in Neuf/Cegetel ISP routers, Club-Internet ISP CI-Box and many 
others. Some commands, like \textbf{cat} might be left here and be used to 
determine the Linux kernel version.

\subsubsection{Analysing a binary firmware image}

You are very likely to find a firmware binary image on the manufacturer website,
even if your device runs a proprietary operating system. If so, you can download
it and use an hexadecimal editor to find printable words such as \textbf{vmlinux},
\textbf{linux}, \textbf{ramdisk}, \textbf{mtd} and others.

Some Unix tools like \textbf{hexdump} or \textbf{strings} can be used to analyse 
the firmware. Below there is an example with a binary firmware found other the Internet:

\begin{verbatim}
hexdump -C <binary image.extension> | less (more)
00000000  46 49 52 45 32 2e 35 2e  30 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |FIRE2.5.0.......|
00000010  00 00 00 00 31 2e 30 2e  30 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |....1.0.0.......|
00000020  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 38  00 43 36 29 00 0a e6 dc  |.......8.C6)..??|
00000030  54 49 44 45 92 89 54 66  1f 8b 08 08 f8 10 68 42  |TIDE..Tf....?.hB|
00000040  02 03 72 61 6d 64 69 73  6b 00 ec 7d 09 bc d5 d3  |..ramdisk.?}.???|
00000050  da ff f3 9b f7 39 7b ef  73 f6 19 3b 53 67 ea 44  |???.?9{?s?.;Sg?D|
\end{verbatim}

Scroll over the firmware to find printable words that can be significant.

\subsubsection{Amount of flash memory}

Linux can hardly fit in a 2MB flash device, once you have opened the device and 
located the flash chip, try to find its characteristics on the Internet. If
your flash chip is a 2MB or less device, your device is most likely to run a 
proprietary OS such as WindRiver VxWorks, or a custom manufacturer OS like Zyxel ZynOS.

OpenWrt does not currently run on devices which have 2MB or less of flash memory.
This limitation will probably not be worked around since those devices are most 
of the time micro-routers, or Wireless Access Points, which are not the main 
OpenWrt target.

\subsubsection{Pluging a serial port}

By using a serial port and a level shifter, you may reach the console that is being shown by the device
for debugging or flashing purposes. By analysing the output of this device, you can
easily notice if the device uses a Linux kernel or something different.

\subsection{Finding and using the manufacturer SDK}

Once you are sure your device run a Linux based firmware, you will be able to start
hacking on it. If the manufacturer respected the GPL, it will have released a Sample
Development Kit with the device.

\subsubsection{GPL violations}

Some manufacturers do release a Linux based binary firmware, with no sources at all.
The first step before doing anything is to read the license coming with your device,
then write them about this lack of Open Source code. If the manufacturer answers
you they do not have to release a SDK containing Open Source software, then we 
recommend you get in touch with the gpl-violations.org community.

You will find below a sample letter that can be sent to the manufacturer:

\begin{verse}
Miss, Mister,

I am using a <device name>, and I cannot find neither on your website nor on the 
CD-ROM the open source software used to build or modify the firmware.

In conformance to the GPL license, you have to release the following sources:

\begin{itemize}
\item complete toolchain that made the kernel and applications be compiled (gcc, binutils, libc)
\item tools to build a custom firmware (mksquashfs, mkcramfs ...)
\item kernel sources with patches to make it run on this specific hardware, this does not include binary drivers
\end{itemize}

Thank you very much in advance for your answer.

Best regards, <your name>
\end{verse}

\subsubsection{Using the SDK}

Once the SDK is available, you are most likely not to be able to build a complete
or functional firmware using it, but parts of it, like only the kernel, or only
the root filesystem. Most manufacturers do not really care releasing a tool that
do work every time you uncompress and use it.

You should anyway be able to use the following components:

\begin{itemize}
\item kernel sources with more or less functional patches for your hardware
\item binary drivers linked or to be linked with the shipped kernel version
\item packages of the toolchain used to compile the whole firmware: gcc, binutils, libc or uClibc
\item binary tools to create a valid firmware image
\end{itemize}

Your work can be divided into the following tasks:

\begin{itemize}
\item create a clean patch of the hardware specific part of the linux kernel
\item spot potential kernel GPL violations especially on netfilter and USB stack stuff
\item make the binary drivers work, until there are open source drivers
\item use standard a GNU toolchain to make working executables
\item understand and write open source tools to generate a valid firmware image
\end{itemize}

\subsubsection{Creating a hardware specific kernel patch}

Most of the time, the kernel source that comes along with the SDK is not really 
clean, and is not a standard Linux version, it also has architecture specific 
fixes backported from the \textbf{CVS} or the \textbf{git} repository of the 
kernel development trees. Anyway, some parts can be easily isolated and used as 
a good start to make a vanilla kernel work your hardware.

Some directories are very likely to have local modifications needed to make your
hardware be recognized and used under Linux. First of all, you need to find out 
the linux kernel version that is used by your hardware, this can be found by 
editing the \textbf{linux/Makefile} file.

\begin{verbatim}
head -5 linux-2.x.x/Makefile
VERSION = 2
PATCHLEVEL = x
SUBLEVEL = y
EXTRAVERSION = z
NAME=A fancy name
\end{verbatim}

So now, you know that you have to download a standard kernel tarball at 
\textbf{kernel.org} that matches the version being used by your hardware.

Then you can create a \textbf{diff} file between the two trees, especially for the 
following directories:

\begin{verbatim}
diff -urN linux-2.x.x/arch/<sub architecture> linux-2.x.x-modified/arch/<sub architecture> > 01-architecture.patch
diff -urN linux-2.x.x/include/ linux-2.x.x-modified/include > 02-includes.patch
diff -urN linux-2.x.x/drivers/ linux-2.x.x-modified/drivers > 03-drivers.patch
\end{verbatim}

This will constitute a basic set of three patches that are very likely to contain
any needed modifications that has been made to the stock Linux kernel to run on 
your specific device. Of course, the content produced by the \textbf{diff -urN} 
may not always be relevant, so that you have to clean up those patches to only 
let the "must have" code into them.

The first patch will contain all the code that is needed by the board to be 
initialized at startup, as well as processor detection and other boot time 
specific fixes.

The second patch will contain all useful definitions for that board: addresses, 
kernel granularity, redefinitions, processor family and features ...

The third patch may contain drivers for: serial console, ethernet NIC, wireless 
NIC, USB NIC ... Most of the time this patch contains nothing else than "glue"
code that has been added to make the binary driver work with the Linux kernel. 
This code might not be useful if you plan on writing drivers from scratch for 
this hardware.

\subsubsection{Using the device bootloader}

The bootloader is the first program that is started right after your device has 
been powered on. This program, can be more or less sophisticated, some do let you 
do network booting, USB mass storage booting ... The bootloader is device and 
architecture specific, some bootloaders were designed to be universal such as 
RedBoot or U-Boot so that you can meet those loaders on totally different 
platforms and expect them to behave the same way.

If your device runs a proprietary operating system, you are very likely to deal 
with a proprietary boot loader as well. This may not always be a limitation, 
some proprietary bootloaders can even have source code available (i.e : Broadcom CFE).

According to the bootloader features, hacking on the device will be more or less 
easier. It is very probable that the bootloader, even exotic and rare, has a 
documentation somewhere over the Internet. In order to know what will be possible 
with your bootloader and the way you are going to hack the device, look over the 
following features :

\begin{itemize}
\item does the bootloader allow net booting via bootp/DHCP/NFS or tftp
\item does the bootloader accept loading ELF binaries ?
\item does the bootloader have a kernel/firmware size limitation ?
\item does the bootloader expect a firmware format to be loaded with ?
\item are the loaded files executed from RAM or flash ?
\end{itemize}

Net booting is something very convenient, because you will only have to set up network
booting servers on your development station, and keep the original firmware on the device
till you are sure you can replace it. This also prevents your device from being flashed,
and potentially bricked every time you want to test a modification on the kernel/filesystem.

If your device needs to be flashed every time you load a firmware, the bootlader might
only accept a specific firmware format to be loaded, so that you will have to 
understand the firmware format as well.

\subsubsection{Making binary drivers work}

As we have explained before, manufacturers do release binary drivers in their GPL
tarball. When those drivers are statically linked into the kernel, they become GPL
as well, fortunately or unfortunately, most of the drivers are not statically linked.
This anyway lets you a chance to dynamically link the driver with the current kernel
version, and try to make them work together.

This is one of the most tricky and grey part of the fully open source projects. 
Some drivers require few modifications to be working with your custom kernel, 
because they worked with an earlier kernel, and few modifications have been made
to the kernel in-between those versions. This is for instance the case with the 
binary driver of the Broadcom BCM43xx Wireless Chipsets, where only few differences
were made to the network interface structures.

Some general principles can be applied no matter which kernel version is used in
order to make binary drivers work with your custom kernel:

\begin{itemize}
\item turn on kernel debugging features such as:
\begin{itemize}
\item CONFIG\_DEBUG\_KERNEL
\item CONFIG\_DETECT\_SOFTLOCKUP
\item CONFIG\_DEBUG\_KOBJECT
\item CONFIG\_KALLSYMS
\item CONFIG\_KALLSYMS\_ALL
\end{itemize}
\item link binary drivers when possible to the current kernel version
\item try to load those binary drivers
\item catch the lockups and understand them
\end{itemize}

Most of the time, loading binary drivers will fail, and generate a kernel oops. 
You can know the last symbol the binary drivers attempted to use, and see in the
kernel headers file, if you do not have to move some structures field before or 
after that symbol in order to keep compatibily with both the binary driver and 
the stock kernel drivers.

\subsubsection{Understanding the firmware format}

You might want to understand the firmware format, even if you are not yet capable
of running a custom firmware on your device, because this is sometimes a blocking
part of the flashing process.

A firmware format is most of the time composed of the following fields:

\begin{itemize}
\item header, containing a firmware version and additional fields: Vendor, Hardware version ...
\item CRC32 checksum on either the whole file or just part of it
\item Binary and/or compressed kernel image
\item Binary and/or compressed root filesystem image
\item potential garbage
\end{itemize}

Once you have figured out how the firmware format is partitioned, you will have 
to write your own tool that produces valid firmware binaries. One thing to be very
careful here is the endianness of either the machine that produces the binary 
firmware and the device that will be flashed using this binary firmware.

\subsubsection{Writing a flash map driver}

The flash map driver has an important role in making your custom firmware work 
because it is responsible of mapping the correct flash regions and associated 
rights to specific parts of the system such as: bootloader, kernel, user filesystem.

Writing your own flash map driver is not really a hard task once you know how your
firmware image and flash is structured. You will find below a commented example
that covers the case of the device where the bootloader can pass to the kernel its partition plan.

First of all, you need to make your flash map driver be visible in the kernel 
configuration options, this can be done by editing the file \
\textbf{linux/drivers/mtd/maps/Kconfig}:

\begin{verbatim}
config MTD_DEVICE_FLASH
        tristate "Device Flash device"
        depends on ARCHITECTURE && DEVICE
        help
         Flash memory access on DEVICE boards. Currently only works with
         Bootloader Foo and Bootloader Bar.
\end{verbatim}

Then add your source file to the \textbf{linux/drivers/mtd/maps/Makefile}, so 
that it will be compiled along with the kernel.

\begin{verbatim}
obj-\$(CONFIG_MTD_DEVICE_FLASH)      += device-flash.o
\end{verbatim}

You can then write the kernel driver itself, by creating a 
\textbf{linux/drivers/mtd/maps/device-flash.c} C source file.

\begin{verbatim}
// Includes that are required for the flash map driver to know of the prototypes:
#include <asm/io.h>
#include <linux/init.h>
#include <linux/kernel.h>
#include <linux/mtd/map.h>
#include <linux/mtd/mtd.h>
#include <linux/mtd/partitions.h>
#include <linux/vmalloc.h>

// Put some flash map definitions here:
#define WINDOW_ADDR 0x1FC00000         /* Real address of the flash */
#define WINDOW_SIZE 0x400000                /* Size of flash */
#define BUSWIDTH 2                                   /* Buswidth */

static void __exit device_mtd_cleanup(void);

static struct mtd_info *device_mtd_info;

static struct map_info devicd_map = {
       .name = "device",
       .size = WINDOW_SIZE,
       .bankwidth = BUSWIDTH,
       .phys = WINDOW_ADDR,
};

static int __init device_mtd_init(void)
{
	  // Display that we found a flash map device 
       printk("device: 0x\%08x at 0x\%08x\n", WINDOW_SIZE, WINDOW_ADDR);
	   // Remap the device address to a kernel address
       device_map.virt = ioremap(WINDOW_ADDR, WINDOW_SIZE);

       // If impossible to remap, exit with the EIO error
       if (!device_map.virt) {
               printk("device: Failed to ioremap\n");
               return -EIO;
       }

	   // Initialize the device map
       simple_map_init(&device_map);

	   /* MTD informations are closely linked to the flash map device
	       you might also use "jedec_probe" "amd_probe" or "intel_probe" */
       device_mtd_info = do_map_probe("cfi_probe", &device_map);

 		if (device_mtd_info) {
               device_mtd_info->owner = THIS_MODULE;

				int parsed_nr_parts = 0;

						// We try here to use the partition schema provided by the bootloader specific code
                       if (parsed_nr_parts == 0) {
                               int ret = parse_bootloader_partitions(device_mtd_info, &parsed_parts, 0);
                               if (ret > 0) {
                                       part_type = "BootLoader";
                                       parsed_nr_parts = ret;
                               }
                       }

                       add_mtd_partitions(devicd_mtd_info, parsed_parts, parsed_nr_parts);

                       return 0;
               }
       iounmap(device_map.virt);

       return -ENXIO;
}

// This function will make the driver clean up the MTD device mapping
static void __exit device_mtd_cleanup(void)
{
	  // If we found a MTD device before
       if (device_mtd_info) {
			   // Delete every partitions
               del_mtd_partitions(device_mtd_info);
			   // Delete the associated map
               map_destroy(device_mtd_info);
       }
	
		// If the virtual address is already in use
       if (device_map.virt) {
					// Unmap the physical address to a kernel space address
               iounmap(device_map.virt);
				// Reset the structure field
              device_map.virt = 0;
       }
}


// Macros that indicate which function is called on loading/unloading the module
module_init(device_mtd_init);
module_exit(device_mtd_cleanup);


// Macros defining license and author, parameters can be defined here too.
MODULE_LICENSE("GPL");
MODULE_AUTHOR("Me, myself and I <memyselfandi@domain.tld");
\end{verbatim}

\subsection{Adding your target in OpenWrt}

Once you spotted the key changes that were made to the Linux kernel
to support your target, you will want to create a target in OpenWrt
for your hardware. This can be useful to benefit from the toolchain
that OpenWrt builds as well as the resulting user-space and kernel
configuration options.

Provided that your target is already known to OpenWrt, it will be
as simple as creating a \texttt{target/linux/board} directory
where you will be creating the following directories and files.

Here for example, is a \texttt{target/linux/board/Makefile}:

\begin{Verbatim}[frame=single,numbers=left]
#
# Copyright (C) 2009 OpenWrt.org
#
# This is free software, licensed under the GNU General Public License v2.
# See /LICENSE for more information.
#
include $(TOPDIR)/rules.mk

ARCH:=mips
BOARD:=board
BOARDNAME:=Eval board
FEATURES:=squashfs jffs2 pci usb

LINUX_VERSION:=2.6.27.10

include $(INCLUDE_DIR)/target.mk

DEFAULT_PACKAGES += hostapd-mini

define Target/Description
        Build firmware images for Evaluation board
endef

$(eval $(call BuildTarget))
\end{Verbatim}

\begin{itemize}
    \item \texttt{ARCH} \\
        The name of the architecture known by Linux and uClibc
    \item \texttt{BOARD} \\
        The name of your board that will be used as a package and build directory identifier
    \item \texttt{BOARDNAME} \\
        Expanded name that will appear in menuconfig
    \item \texttt{FEATURES} \\
        Set of features to build filesystem images, USB, PCI, VIDEO kernel support
    \item \texttt{LINUX\_VERSION} \\
        Linux kernel version to use for this target
    \item \texttt{DEFAULT\_PACKAGES} \\
        Set of packages to be built by default
\end{itemize}

A partial kernel configuration which is either named \texttt{config-default} or which matches the kernel version \texttt{config-2.6.x} should be present in \texttt{target/linux/board/}.
This kernel configuration will only contain the relevant symbols to support your target and can be changed using \texttt{make kernel\_menuconfig}.

To patch the kernel sources with the patches required to support your hardware, you will have to drop them in \texttt{patches} or in \texttt{patches-2.6.x} if there are specific
changes between kernel versions. Additionnaly, if you want to avoid creating a patch that will create files, you can put those files into \texttt{files} or \texttt{files-2.6.x}
with the same directory structure that the kernel uses (e.g: drivers/mtd/maps, arch/mips ..).

The build system will require you to create a \texttt{target/linux/board/image/Makefile}:

\begin{Verbatim}[frame=single,numbers=left]
#
# Copyright (C) 2009 OpenWrt.org
#
# This is free software, licensed under the GNU General Public License v2.
# See /LICENSE for more information.
#
include $(TOPDIR)/rules.mk
include $(INCLUDE_DIR)/image.mk

define Image/BuildKernel
        cp $(KDIR)/vmlinux.elf $(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-vmlinux.elf
        gzip -9 -c $(KDIR)/vmlinux > $(KDIR)/vmlinux.bin.gz
        $(STAGING_DIR_HOST)/bin/lzma e $(KDIR)/vmlinux $(KDIR)/vmlinux.bin.l7
        dd if=$(KDIR)/vmlinux.bin.l7 of=$(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-vmlinux.lzma bs=65536 conv=sync
        dd if=$(KDIR)/vmlinux.bin.gz of=$(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-vmlinux.gz bs=65536 conv=sync
endef

define Image/Build/squashfs
    $(call prepare_generic_squashfs,$(KDIR)/root.squashfs)
endef

define Image/Build
        $(call Image/Build/$(1))
        dd if=$(KDIR)/root.$(1) of=$(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-root.$(1) bs=128k conv=sync

        -$(STAGING_DIR_HOST)/bin/mkfwimage \
                -B XS2 -v XS2.ar2316.OpenWrt \
                -k $(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-vmlinux.lzma \
                -r $(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-root.$(1) \
                -o $(BIN_DIR)/openwrt-$(BOARD)-ubnt2-$(1).bin
endef

$(eval $(call BuildImage))

\end{Verbatim}

\begin{itemize}
    \item \texttt{Image/BuildKernel} \\
        This template defines changes to be made to the ELF kernel file
    \item \texttt{Image/Build} \\
	This template defines the final changes to apply to the rootfs and kernel, either combined or separated
	firmware creation tools can be called here as well.
\end{itemize}